Meatloaf Sauce from Ohio’s Amish Country 2 Jars – Walnut Creek Foods

$20.98

A 2-pack of Walnut Creek Meatloaf Sauce — brown sugar, tomato, vinegar in the right ratio for caramelizing on top of a Sunday meatloaf. Made in the USA.

Prices change frequently — check current availability now.

Product details and origin based on manufacturer listings — verify before purchase.

Key Features

  • 2-pack of Walnut Creek Foods Meatloaf Sauce — Ohio Amish-country brown-sugar-and-tomato-vinegar topping
  • Dense enough to caramelize on the loaf's top instead of running off during the bake
  • Sweet and slightly tangy in the right ratio — Sunday-dinner meatloaf topping the household cooks made
  • Two-jar pack covers a year of meatloaf nights or pairs as a gift with apple butter BBQ sauce
  • Made in the USA by Walnut Creek Foods — traditional Amish-country preserves in eastern Ohio
🍳 Kitchen Essential🏠 Everyday Home Upgrade🎁 Great Gift Idea

A 2-pack of Walnut Creek Foods Meatloaf Sauce from Ohio’s Amish Country — the brown-sugar-and-tomato-vinegar topping that the household cooks brushed onto meatloaf an hour before pulling it out of the oven. Sweet, slightly tangy, and dense enough to caramelize on the loaf’s top instead of running off.

This is the sauce for buyers who grew up with meatloaf as a Sunday-dinner staple and want the right topping back. Two jars covers a year of meatloaf nights or makes a tidy gift-pack alongside the apple butter BBQ sauce.

Walnut Creek Foods packs traditional Amish-country preserves and sauces in eastern Ohio — Made in the USA.

See an issue with this product?

Tell us if this product is unavailable, incorrectly categorized, no longer American-made, or if you know of a better alternative.

Report Product Issue →

Buy with Confidence

Every product featured on Buy American Campaign is researched, verified, and clearly labeled — so you can shop confidently and support American manufacturing.

How This Store Works

Why You Can Trust This Store

Every product here is verified American-made — and we do not sell anything ourselves. We point you to the maker or retailer, so you always buy direct.

Made in USA Verified
We check where products are actually manufactured before we list them.
We Do Not Sell Anything
You buy from the retailer. We never handle your payment or shipping details.
No Paid Listings
Companies cannot pay to appear here or to rank higher.
Corrections Welcome
If a Made in USA claim is wrong, tell us and we will fix it.
Buy American Store
Verified American-Made. Every Product.

A curated catalog of products that are genuinely made in the USA — so you can put your dollars behind the companies still building here.

Follow us on

The Buy American Store is a curated catalog of American-made products, from cast iron cookware and hand tools to kitchen goods, apparel, and outdoor gear. Every listing is checked to confirm the product is genuinely manufactured in the United States.

We do not sell products directly. We link you to the retailer, and we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you — which funds the work of finding and verifying Made in USA products.

© 2026 Buy American Store. Part of the Buy American Campaign.Privacy PolicyContact